Close Menu
The Baylor Lariat
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    Trending
    • Students react to emergency alert following campus lockdown
    • Baylor shelter-in-place lifted following police pursuit of robbery suspects
    • Baylor graduate charged after killing cats with pellet gun, hanging bodies over utility lines
    • Baylor Football’s Alex Foster dies at 18
    • Board of Regents confirms budget, renovations, new leadership in May meeting
    • How facilities responds to storms, flooding in campus buildings
    • Welcome Week leaders now paid in hopes of increasing numbers
    • 5 Baylor sports storylines to look forward to in 2025-26
    • About us
      • Spring 2025 Staff Page
      • Copyright Information
    • Contact
      • Contact Information
      • Letters to the Editor
      • Subscribe to The Morning Buzz
      • Department of Student Media
    • Employment
    • PDF Archives
    • RSS Feeds
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    The Baylor LariatThe Baylor Lariat
    Subscribe to the Morning Buzz
    Friday, July 4
    • News
      • State and National News
        • State
        • National
      • Politics
        • 2025 Inauguration Page
        • Election Page
      • Homecoming Page
      • Baylor News
      • Waco Updates
      • Campus and Waco Crime
    • Arts & Life
      • Wedding Edition 2025
      • What to Do in Waco
      • Campus Culture
      • Indy and Belle
      • Sing 2025
      • Leisure and Travel
        • Leisure
        • Travel
          • Baylor in Ireland
      • Student Spotlight
      • Local Scene
        • Small Businesses
        • Social Media
      • Arts and Entertainment
        • Art
        • Fashion
        • Food
        • Literature
        • Music
        • Film and Television
    • Opinion
      • Editorials
      • Points of View
      • Lariat Letters
    • Sports
      • March Madness 2025
      • Football
      • Basketball
        • Men’s Basketball
        • Women’s Basketball
      • Soccer
      • Baseball
      • Softball
      • Volleyball
      • Equestrian
      • Cross Country and Track & Field
      • Acrobatics & Tumbling
      • Tennis
      • Golf
      • Pro Sports
      • Sports Takes
      • Club Sports
    • Lariat TV News
    • Multimedia
      • Video Features
      • Podcasts
        • Don’t Feed the Bears
      • Slideshows
    • Advertising
    The Baylor Lariat
    Home»Opinion»Editorials

    Editorial: NY Times incorrectly put teacher in bad light

    By October 20, 2011 Editorials No Comments3 Mins Read
    Esteban Diaz | Editorial Cartoonist
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email
    Esteban Diaz | Editorial Cartoonist

    Everyone knows that there are two sides to a story…except, evidently, The New York Times.

    When reporting on a 16-year-old stutterer who claimed to be discriminated against at a community college, the New York Times ran what was a rather one-sided article on the front page of the paper. This was inappropriate and a crass attempt at creating an artificial controversy.

    Imagine that you’re a teacher who has a student who speaks more often in class than others, so you ask him to ask fewer questions in class. The student is taking college classes two years early and admits to speaking primarily in paragraph form instead of short sentences. Your stated reason for calling on him less is to avoid infringing on the time of the other students.

    Did you act inappropriately? It sure doesn’t seem that way. This is the exact situation that Elizabeth Snyder found herself in with a student by the name of Phillip Garber Jr., who was speaking in class more often in class than the other students.

    She, however, found herself on the front page of the New York Times as having acted inappropriately.

    Why? Phillip Garber Jr. is an admitted stutterer and claims that he was discriminated against because of his stuttering, not his behavior.

    The truth probably lies somewhere between the version that Garber offers and the version that Snyder offers. We are inclined to lean toward Snyder’s version, but we obviously weren’t in the room and will never know the real story.

    We are, however, doing two things rather differently from the New York Times. One is that we are writing this in an opinion piece and not in a news piece and the second is that we are acknowledging that both sides probably have some truth to their claims.

    While the original story ran on the front page of the New York Times, a follow-up piece ran a full four days later that was a little less critical of Snyder.

    Unlike the first piece, however, this piece ran on page A21, not the front page. That pretty much says it all about what the New York Times’ priority when it wrote this story.

    It wasn’t getting this story into the public spotlight – it was generating controversy.

    Snyder was the one who lost out.

    The New York Times should be more careful in the future when it takes a non-public figure like Snyder and throws her into the public spotlight. Garber may have wanted to complain in public, but that doesn’t mean that he was right.

    New York Times

    Keep Reading

    Don’t believe myths about autism — reduce stigma by learning facts

    Childhood interests don’t have to stay in the past

    Support international students during visa revocations

    We find inspiration between pages, so should you

    Let us change your mind about journalism in 5 minutes

    AI Studio Ghibli images aren’t as cool as you think

    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    Recent Posts
    • Students react to emergency alert following campus lockdown June 27, 2025
    • Baylor shelter-in-place lifted following police pursuit of robbery suspects June 26, 2025
    About

    The award-winning student newspaper of Baylor University since 1900.

    Articles, photos, and other works by staff of The Baylor Lariat are Copyright © Baylor® University. All rights reserved.

    Subscribe to the Morning Buzz

    Get the latest Lariat News by just Clicking Subscribe!

    Follow the Live Coverage
    Tweets by @bulariat

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    • Featured
    • News
    • Sports
    • Opinion
    • Arts and Life
    © 2025 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.