Close Menu
The Baylor Lariat
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    Trending
    • Students react to emergency alert following campus lockdown
    • Baylor shelter-in-place lifted following police pursuit of robbery suspects
    • Baylor graduate charged after killing cats with pellet gun, hanging bodies over utility lines
    • Baylor Football’s Alex Foster dies at 18
    • Board of Regents confirms budget, renovations, new leadership in May meeting
    • How facilities responds to storms, flooding in campus buildings
    • Welcome Week leaders now paid in hopes of increasing numbers
    • 5 Baylor sports storylines to look forward to in 2025-26
    • About us
      • Spring 2025 Staff Page
      • Copyright Information
    • Contact
      • Contact Information
      • Letters to the Editor
      • Subscribe to The Morning Buzz
      • Department of Student Media
    • Employment
    • PDF Archives
    • RSS Feeds
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    The Baylor LariatThe Baylor Lariat
    Subscribe to the Morning Buzz
    Monday, June 30
    • News
      • State and National News
        • State
        • National
      • Politics
        • 2025 Inauguration Page
        • Election Page
      • Homecoming Page
      • Baylor News
      • Waco Updates
      • Campus and Waco Crime
    • Arts & Life
      • Wedding Edition 2025
      • What to Do in Waco
      • Campus Culture
      • Indy and Belle
      • Sing 2025
      • Leisure and Travel
        • Leisure
        • Travel
          • Baylor in Ireland
      • Student Spotlight
      • Local Scene
        • Small Businesses
        • Social Media
      • Arts and Entertainment
        • Art
        • Fashion
        • Food
        • Literature
        • Music
        • Film and Television
    • Opinion
      • Editorials
      • Points of View
      • Lariat Letters
    • Sports
      • March Madness 2025
      • Football
      • Basketball
        • Men’s Basketball
        • Women’s Basketball
      • Soccer
      • Baseball
      • Softball
      • Volleyball
      • Equestrian
      • Cross Country and Track & Field
      • Acrobatics & Tumbling
      • Tennis
      • Golf
      • Pro Sports
      • Sports Takes
      • Club Sports
    • Lariat TV News
    • Multimedia
      • Video Features
      • Podcasts
        • Don’t Feed the Bears
      • Slideshows
    • Advertising
    The Baylor Lariat
    Home»Opinion»Editorials

    Editorial: Gas chambers are cruel and unusual

    Baylor LariatBy Baylor LariatApril 27, 2015 Editorials No Comments4 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    AlternativePunishmentIn response to a shortage of drugs used in lethal injection, several states that wish to executions as punishment are looking at alternatives — one being the gas chamber.

    This past week, Oklahoma governor Mary Fallin signed into a law a measure that would institute the nitrogen-backed gas chamber, a law currently pending approval from the U.S. Supreme Court.

    Fallin said she believes ”capital punishment must be performed effectively and without cruelty,” and the bill she signed gives Oklahoma another death penalty option that meets that standard.

    But considering execution by gas chambers in the past have caused asphyxiation to inmates, often leaving them gasping for breath for in some instances almost 20 minutes, Fallin is severely mistaken.

    Over the past year, a number of capital punishment cases employing lethal injection have come under the national spotlight.

    This is primarily because trials using lethal, experimental drug cocktails have been deemed unsuccessful. Last year, Joseph Wood, an inmate convicted and sentenced to death for the 1989 murder of his ex-girlfriend and her father, was injected 15 times with a lethal dose of drugs.

    A procedure which y should have been completed with one dose was protracted to almost two hours. Witnesses who were at Wood’s execution said Wood spent over an hour of the execution “gasping and snorting.”

    An attorney for Wood said although he is not sure whether or not he suffered, one thing is certain: the first attempt was unsuccessful.

    One of the prevailing reasons for using these “experimental” chemicals is the fact that many states that still use capital punishment are running out of the drugs for  lethal injection.

    Texas’ state department confirmed last month that the state only had enough dosage for one lethal injection left. Europe supplies the U.S. with many of these drugs. Europe has placed an embargo on the drugs pentobarbital and sodium thiopental, which are commonly used for lethal injection, so many states are facing the same lack of drugs.

    Catherine Ashton, who served as the vice president of the European Commission at the time the embargo was passed, said it was passed as part of the European Union’s wider effort to eradicate the death penalty nationwide, according to an article published by The Independent.

    The gas chamber was a form of execution last used in the U.S. in Arizona in 1999. Since then, lethal injection has been the primary means for corporal punishment.

    Although the Supreme Court has never ruled on the constitutionality of the gas chamber, several legal experts argue that the use of the chamber violates the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

    In 1996, U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a decision by U.S. District Judge Marilyn H. Patel in San Francisco three years earlier, who stated in her decision that the gas chamber was “inhumane and has no place in civilized society.”

    At the heart of the issue lies one question: Does the person being executed feel pain during the gas chamber execution? This was the basis of the switch for many states from electric chairs and gas chambers to lethal injections.

    Fallin claims that these nitrogen-based gas chambers will have a similar effect that proponents of lethal injection used to champion the penalty.

    Hydrogen cyanide and carbon monoxide have been used in the past for the gas chamber. Fallin says nitrogen gas would cause the person being executed to fall unconscious almost immediately, therefore rendering the execution in a sense, humane.

    Dr. Joel Zivot, however, says it is “ethically impossible” to reach a conclusion on execution procedures, since medicine does not position itself to intentionally take a life.

    Zivot, who is the assistant professor of anesthesiology and surgery at Emory University School of Medicine, said, “There’s no therapeutic use of nitrogen gas, and there’s no way to ethically or practically test if nitrogen gas is a humane alternative,” in an interview with the Huffington Post.

    If scientists were to “test” an individual to see whether or not they experienced pain during the procedure, there would be no way to tell whether or not the deceased person experienced pain. It’s a no-win situation.

    It is not clear whether or not the death penalty should be abolished completely.

    There are several arguments for and against the form of punishment that are at the very least worth considering.

    However, if a state is to employ capital punishment as a means of punishing individuals who commit heinous crimes, there needs to be a complete assurance that the the means of execution is humane.

    Otherwise, another method should be used. The nitrogen-based gas chamber method does not meet that criterion and should not be employed.

    capital punishement gas chamber Lethal Injection Mary Fallin
    Baylor Lariat

    Keep Reading

    Students react to emergency alert following campus lockdown

    Baylor shelter-in-place lifted following police pursuit of robbery suspects

    Baylor graduate charged after killing cats with pellet gun, hanging bodies over utility lines

    Baylor Football’s Alex Foster dies at 18

    Board of Regents confirms budget, renovations, new leadership in May meeting

    How facilities responds to storms, flooding in campus buildings

    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    Recent Posts
    • Students react to emergency alert following campus lockdown June 27, 2025
    • Baylor shelter-in-place lifted following police pursuit of robbery suspects June 26, 2025
    About

    The award-winning student newspaper of Baylor University since 1900.

    Articles, photos, and other works by staff of The Baylor Lariat are Copyright © Baylor® University. All rights reserved.

    Subscribe to the Morning Buzz

    Get the latest Lariat News by just Clicking Subscribe!

    Follow the Live Coverage
    Tweets by @bulariat

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    • Featured
    • News
    • Sports
    • Opinion
    • Arts and Life
    © 2025 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.