By Stephanie Starks | Staff Writer
Named after its owner’s two sons, Nicolas Matthew is a new diner, bakery and deli rooted in family.
The restaurant, which had its grand opening Monday, is located at 5900 Bosque Blvd. and seeks to offer Waco a menu based on unique recipes from chef and owner James Quattrocchi and other people who have previously worked with him.
“We have a pink rock cake, which one of my [cooking] partners made,” Quattrocchi said. “She happened to get sick with cancer, and she is in recovery for 40 years. In homage to her, I am doing that chocolate rock cake.”
Quattrocchi started his culinary career 50 years ago. He was self-taught so he found people that he wanted to learn from and overtime he perfected his craft. Since then, he has opened a few 100 restaurants.
Although Quattrocchi has opened many different restaurants, he wanted to bring something distinct to Waco, where he has lived the past 20 years.
“We don’t sell chicken fried steak because everybody in town sells chicken fried steak,” he said. “We don’t sell traditional cookies or cupcakes because that’s what everyone else does. We have some unique recipes. These are old bakery recipes that are maybe 100- to 150-year-old recipes that have been passed down.”
Brittany Sandifer, bakery manager and master of pies, was an emergency room and intensive care unit dialysis nurse for 15 years. She got burnt out on her job very quickly and never felt like she knew what she wanted to do.
“When I was growing up, I was always cooking,” Sandifer said. “I took a lot of inspiration from patients that taught me their ways of making southern food, soul food, pastries and pies. I opened up Pies with a Twist, and I still run that on the side. I did a lot of cooking gigs. I have been in really high roles, and I wasn’t happy with my last place.”
Sandifer wanted to work in a restaurant where there was a “home atmosphere.” She and Quattrocchi were able to connect over similar backgrounds in both their personal and cooking lives. Like Quattrocchi, Sandifer loved doing startup restaurants and still having a “home life and a work life.”
Sandifer said the staff helped furnish all the decor at Nicolas Matthew.
“I love that because it makes people want to take care of it more,” Sandifer said. “It makes [staff] feel more a part of the restaurant. I think deep down that might have been some of [Quattrocchi’s] goal.”
The pinks and blue undertones and the happy atmosphere in Nicolas Matthew make it look like a 1950s style diner. There are pictures on the walls of cakes that employees have worked on before coming to work at Nicolas Matthew and a table with pictures of Quattrocchi’s family on it.
This was an intentional choice by Quattrocchi who said that the restaurant is “not a big corporation.” He wants to make this restaurant feel like home and remind staff of the work that they have done.
“We all have fun together, we all get along, and we have been able to keep that positive vibe here,” she said. “We believe in that process, and we believe in this business.”
Crystal Miller, a gelato baker, was intrigued by the possibility of working in a bakery.
“This is something people want to get more of,” Miller said. “People see this place and they are like, ‘What is that?’ They want to come in here and find out.”
To people who do not know about Nicolas Matthew, Miller said to give it a chance. Out of all the menu items, Miller said that she wants to try the lasagna the most.
“There is a great menu with different choices,” Miller said. “It is going to be very nice when we get things going.”
Nathan Morrill, one of the soft-open customers at Nicolas Matthew, worked at the Hayter House, a restaurant in Nacogdoches, for two years with his college roommate. Since he worked in the baking industry, Morrill was excited for something new to come to Waco.
“I saw the open sign, and I came here and saw,” Morrill said. “Now I am being introduced to treats, and I am going to bring them home to my boys. They are going to be super excited. I am excited about a sandwich shop opening around the corner from my house.”


